For lashes that look a million times multiplied and perfectly defined, there's only one mascara - NEW Voluminous® Million Lashes™. The built-in Clean Sweep Wiping System wipes the brush free of clumps leaving the perfect amount of mascara for an ultra-volumized clean lash look. The Millionizing Brush evenly thickens lashes from root to tip. The result? Lashes look so multiplied, so clean, it's like seeing millions. -lorealparis.ca

For the last two months this has been my non-waterproof mascara (in other words, weekends and non-workday mascara). I must say I have fallen in love with it.
It has a great brush that seems to eliminate clumps and lumps while still catching every lash.

I also just learned that there is a waterproof version, I am going to definitely have to check it out.

me, wearing the mascara

me and the mascara & L'oreal Color Infallible Eyeshadows

Pros:

• Drug store available
• Comes in black brown, black, blackest black, waterproof black, waterproof blackest black, and carbon black. 
• Great effects
• No Clumps

Cons:

• None I can think of

Overall:
I am loving this formal and brush. It has to be one of the best mascaras I've tried in a long time. As I said, going to hunt down the waterproof and give it a shot.